| Platinum | Le Quartier |
| Gold | Goldenrod Pastries |
| Silver | Butterfly Bakery |
| Bronze | Nothing Bundt Cakes Lincoln |
| Top Pick | Et's Sweets |
| Top Pick | LaMar's Donuts & Coffee |
| Top Pick | Noonie's Homemade Fudge |
| Top Pick | Russ's Market |
| Top Pick | Sweet Things by Marcy |
| Top Pick | The Rabbit Hole Bakery |