| Platinum | Bagels & Joe |
| Gold | Penelope's Lil Cafe |
| Silver | The Mill Coffee and Bistro |
| Bronze | Starbucks Coffee |
| Top Pick | Cultiva |
| Top Pick | Meadowlark Coffee and Espresso |
| Top Pick | Mo Java Cafe and Roasting Co. |
| Top Pick | Rose Cat Coffee Company |
| Top Pick | Scooter's Coffee |
| Top Pick | Tina's Restaurant |