| Platinum | Villa Amore |
| Gold | Florio's Italian Restaurant & Grille |
| Silver | Old Chicago Pasta & Pizza |
| Bronze | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Casa De Bovina |
| Top Pick | Momo Pizzeria and Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Napoli's |
| Top Pick | Piezano's |
| Top Pick | Ticos |
| Top Pick | Vincenzo's Ristorante |